ITHACA, NY (607NewsNow) — The ruling from New York State appeals court judge to uphold environmental approval for using the artificial turf is not satisfactory for Zero Waste Ithaca.
The decision, made on November 12th, established that the City of Ithaca Planning Board satisfied its obligations under the State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) regarding the use of artificial turf at Cornell’s Meinig Fieldhouse. Zero Waste Ithaca says, “the court’s ruling does not establish that Cornell’s synthetic turf is free of PFAS or that the City verified compliance with its own approval condition. After more than a year of pursuing public records, ZWI still cannot determine exactly which turf models were installed, which components were tested, or whether Planning staff evaluated and verified compliance.”
The Planning Board’s approval for the artificial turf on September 26th, 2024, required that Cornell submit details of both indoor and outdoor synthetic turf systems, including the performance shock pads, infill, and blades to Planning staff for review, with any issues referred to the Planning Board for review and approval. It also required “third party testing of the artificial turf carpet for the presence of PFAS before it leaves the manufacturer,” with the stated goal that the turf “will not contain or be treated with PFAS,” and to submit the results to the Planning staff, according to Zero Waste Ithaca.
“The Planning Board promised the public this turf would be tested for PFAS. More than a year later, we still don’t know exactly what was tested, and the city has no record that Planning staff ever verified compliance,” said Yayoi Koizumi, Executive Director of Zero Waste Ithaca. “A court ruling on procedure doesn’t tell anyone what’s in the turf.”
The ruling comes after Zero Waste Ithaca called on Cornell University and the City of Ithaca to release PFAS test records last month, though they first requested the compliance records in October 2025. The organization worries that the ruling could open the door to more synthetic turf installations completed without a full environmental impact statement in New York State.
Zero Waste Ithaca remains steadfast in their request for Cornell University and the City of Ithaca to “identify the products installed, provide records connecting the tested samples to those products, disclose any additional testing of turf-system components, and explain how compliance with the Planning Board’s PFAS testing condition was evaluated.”
